gap hr services logo white
HR Services and Employment Law specialist: For Employers
Menu
gap hr services logo white
HR Services and Employment Law specialist: For Employers
Call Us: 01491 598 600 Email Us: cw@gaphr.co.uk

  • Home
  • Services
    • Architects HR
    • Golf HR
    • Hospitality HR
  • Quizzes
    • Quiz
    • Redundancy Quiz
    • Contract Quiz
    • Disciplinary Quiz
  • Resources
    • Blog
    • Redundancy
    • Disciplinaries
    • FAQs
    • Contracts
    • Settlement Agreements
  • About us
    • HR Case Studies
  • Contact us

Filling the GAP in HR services: Insert expletive of your choice

Written by Carolyne Wahlen

It is a real shame that ACAS is falling down in its main job: supporting people who have been unfairly treated by their employers.

We’ve always had a lot of contact on our clients’ behalf with ACAS at the Early Conciliation level (the month before they start an official tribunal).

Their conciliators have always only been a messenger, without legal power and no jurisdiction to decide who is “right”.

Generally they have been very realistic and informed and helpful in the process.

But that was before Coronavirus.

In the past two months, we’ve had to deal with two nightmare “conciliators” who had no idea about the law or how to do their job.

The first one felt that it was unfair (!) that an employee had been fired after 4 months service without following a full disciplinary process.

As you probably know, under 2 years there is no protection from unfair dismissal for employees. And we have in our contracts and handbook that we will not be using the disciplinary process on staff under 2 years.

Absolutely legal.

But the ACAS conciliator had not heard of it, telling me bluntly, “You are not allowed to do that!”.

I advised her to check her facts. Making value judgements in that sort of position, with no legal basis whatsoever, truly is shocking, not least because most employers would not have the legal background to know that the conciliator was talking out of their proverbial.

And then an even worse one cropped up.

We were advising an employee who had been made redundant from a big steel company after 20 years’ service.

She’d gone through the first redundancy process in April last year. She’d applied for the remaining jobs on offer but been told by her line manager (very unprofessionally), that she shouldn’t apply because her job was safe.

Which it was, at that point, so she withdrew her application

The second redundancy process ended in October last year. This time she was made redundant and then realised afterwards, from talking to her colleagues still at work, that the process had been a sham.

So she started Early Conciliation.

Bearing in mind that very few employees are in a good place when they start this process, the conciliator she spoke to was rude and professionally negligent, and from this moment forward I will refer to them as [insert expletive of your choice].

Claire said that she had not been offered all the jobs available in the process and the [insert expletive of your choice] conciliator said that the company did not need to do that.

Instead, it was apparently Claire’s responsibility to look on the company website to see what jobs were being advertised, and then apply for them.

Wrong.

The company said that they did not need to offer her all the positions anyway because she had withdrawn from the first redundancy process (after her manager told her to) so she obviously wasn’t interested in anything they had to offer in the second process.

Wrong, wrong, wrong.

Claire was asked by the [insert expletive of your choice] conciliator what she would like as an outcome.

The penalty for unfair dismissal is a year’s pay plus a 25% uplift. So that is what she asked for.

Then came the worst value judgement statement I have ever heard from an ACAS conciliator:

“Oh you will never get that. 2 or 3 months at the most. You do know that it is not the employer’s job to pay your bills while you sit at home and drink coffee and watch TV, don’t you?”!

OMG!

Leaving aside that that is exactly what a sizable proportion of the working population is doing under furlough, the statement is ABSOLUTELY legally wrong and unprofessional.

Claire was in tears when she spoke to me about it. She’d been made to feel that she had no hope, that she was being over-emotional, demanding and wasting ACAS’ time.

I reassured her that she did have a case, that the conciliator was a [insert expletive of your choice], and that the next step was a full tribunal claim.

My theory on these behaviours?

  • That ACAS has been given orders to squash any and all claims so that they do not go to tribunal.
  • By whatever means necessary.
  • By giving false legal judgements.
  • By destroying employees who have been dismissed unfairly and stopping them from a tribunal because they think, incorrectly, that they have no case.

ACAS is supposed to be neutral and fact based.

Unfortunately, it seems that their professionalism is another casualty of the pandemic.

If you get an Early Conciliation claim, call us so that you cannot be treated as horrendously in your dealings with ACAS.

Filed Under: Uncategorized

golf hr book

Click here to download


ticks

Never worry about going to tribunal again!

BOOK NOW!

Do it, before it's too late!

carolyne wahlen

About Carolyne

Carolyne has run a successful business since 2003, is a well-respected speaker, and author of all things HR. There are many, many business owners across the country who have had their very stressful employee issues magically disappear because they’ve teamed up with Carolyne and Gap HR.

Why Gap HR?

We exist to help you stay legal, compliant and profitable, without shelling out for an in-house HR manager. Over 180 clients benefit from the experience and expertise of the Gap HR team.

 

Call us on 01491 598 600

Email me on cw@gaphr.co.uk

 

Click here to download

Ask a Question

  • If you are an employee and feel that you have been treated badly, then we strongly advise you to contact ACAS:

    Call the ACAS Helpline on 0300 123 1100 for free support and advice.

    Simply get in touch and they'll provide you with clear and confidential guidance about any kind of dispute or query that you have about relationship issues within the workplace.

    You may want to know about employment rights and rules, best practice or you may need advice about a dispute.

    Whatever it is, just give ACAS a call, their team are on hand to respond within the hours: Monday-Friday, 8am-8pm and Saturday, 9am-1pm.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Where our clients are:

View Gap clients in a full screen map

“We have been using Gap HR for several years now. Carolyne and her team are professional and efficient and we would not hesitate in recommending them for small businesses. It is a great relief to know we are supported by them for our HR advice and paperwork is kept up to date.”

Deb Green, Vermatech Pest Control

“I have been working with Carolyne and her team for 6 years now , when I first purchased 2Excel Logistics I found the HR scary as I wanted to do the right thing for my staff , with Gap HR on my side this all seemed easy and we have gone from 9 staff to 28 with no hassle what so ever , thank you to all at Gap HR”

Justin Wilkie, 2Excel Logistics

“So pleased to be working with Gap HR. They’ve straightened us out in no time. Their pricing is clear and they really know what they are talking about.”

Ashley Lewis, Wallingford Tiles and Bathrooms

“We are a growing company but do not have facilities in house yet for HR services in house. Gap HR is our go to service for all kinds of advice about HR for our business and we have found them very reliable, communicative and efficient. Would definitely recommend them”

Helen Gordon, Kitecreative

“Carolyne and team continue to provide great support to our business, with quick and accurate responses to help with our various HR needs.”

Gap HR Services Logo

“Gap HR have been at our side for a number of years now and are a great help in dealing with our HR needs”

Copyright © 2022 Name & Registered Office:

Gap HR Services Ltd.
Wallingford Road, Goring, Reading, RG8 0HN, UK
Phone: 01491 598 600

Company No. 08146299 | Contact us | Privacy & Cookies Policy | About this Website